Cast Iron Care for People Who Are Scared of It

Overhead view of a thick, marbled ribeye steak sprinkled with coarse sea salt, sizzling in a black cast-iron skillet on a dark wooden table, lit by warm golden morning sunlight as steam rises.

A lot of people own a cast iron pan and never use it. They heard you can't wash it, that one mistake ruins it, that it needs a ritual. Most of that is myth. Cast iron is one of the hardest pans in the kitchen to actually ruin, and it gets better the more you cook in it.

Everything below comes from how we do it and from Lodge's own care guides, linked at the bottom.

What seasoning actually is

Seasoning is just oil baked onto the iron. When oil is heated hot enough, it turns from a liquid into a hard, slick layer that bonds to the pan. Every time you cook with oil or fat, you add a little more of it. That's why the best way to keep a pan seasoned is simply to use it.

The everyday routine: wash, dry, oil

  1. Wash. Warm water, a little dish soap if you want it, and a stiff brush or scrub pad. Lodge says modern dish soap isn't strong enough to strip seasoning.
  2. Dry. Right away and completely. A towel, then a minute on a low burner if you want to be sure.
  3. Oil. A very thin layer, rubbed in with a paper towel. If it drips or runs when you tilt the pan, that's too much.

That's it. Two minutes after dinner.

The three things to avoid

  • Soaking it. Standing water is what causes rust. For stuck food, use a scraper or a nylon brush instead.
  • The dishwasher. It strips the seasoning and will likely rust the pan.
  • Air drying. Same problem as soaking, just slower.

When something goes wrong

Rust. It happens, and it's fixable. Scrub the rust off with steel wool, wash, dry completely, and oil. If a lot of seasoning came off with it, reseason (below).

Sticky or gummy surface. That's too much oil that never fully baked on. Put the pan upside down in the oven at 450 to 500°F for an hour and the stickiness goes away.

Flakes. Small dark flakes are bits of carbonized oil. Lodge says they aren't harmful. Usually more cooking fixes it.

Dull or patchy. Usually the pan got heated without enough oil. Reseason it.

How to reseason

Wash and dry the pan completely. Rub a very thin layer of oil over the whole thing, inside and out. Put foil on the lower rack, set the pan upside down on the rack above, and bake at 450 to 500°F for one hour. Turn the oven off and let the pan cool inside it.

How we use ours

We season ours with beef tallow or avocado oil. After cooking, we clean it by wiping it out with a paper towel or a towel. That's usually enough, and the pan keeps getting better the more we sear in it.

Why it matters to us

A good pan is one of the few things you can buy once and keep for decades. It pairs well with buying good beef from people who raise it well, which we wrote about in Steak and Soil. Treat the pan simply, use it often, and it'll outlast you.

Sources